Last year when we put on a new roof to our house, I scrambled to come up with a new home media wiring plan. The wires only cost maybe $200 for all-you-can-eat HDMI and cat6, and the roof costs closer to $25K. So, while we had the plywood decking ripped up, we had the roofers run a cat6 and HDMI everywhere that I wanted it.
Shortly after that project was done, I cut through our living room walls to install the HDMI and cat6 wall jacks using the simple but very versatile generic blank wall plate + keystone low voltage wall jacks from pchcables (and many other places). No more running a wire across the room in order to watch a DVD! This alone was reason for rejoicing.
A year later, bluray players have gotten extremely cheap, perhaps because everybody is banking on new 3D technology? But I’ve got an old (1 year old) Epson Powerlite 6100 projector with no plan for 3D in my future, and a bluray player is a highly desired upgrade from my old 480p Oppo DVD player.
I settled on the Panasonic DMP-BD60 player as the reviews were pretty good and the price unbeatable.
Very excited about the possibility of the 600 new lines of resolution my projector will start displaying, I plugged it in on Friday night. It was sort of like turning the key on the car, and only hearing the starter. My projector indicated to me that it can’t display the image and the DVD player sent a cryptic message “U73″, indicating a ’serious’ HDMI error. Ugh. After an hour of tinkering, I have proven that with a short cable, everything ‘just works’. But with my 50 foot HDMI cable, tucked away in the rafters of my home, it fails to start up.
I modified the DVD player settings to use 1080i, and the signal goes through fine. Sigh. As it turns out, not all cables are created equal, and even though a cable is ‘rated’ for 50 feet of HDMI 1.3a, that doesn’t mean that it will work with all DVD players and projectors.
I looked a bit into the specs to demystify 1080i vs. 1080p (default setting). I didn’t get it - why would 1080i work but 1080p doesn’t work? The simple answer: bandwidth. With 1080p, there is a full 60Hz frame rate sent to the projector. With 1080i, it also sends images at 60Hz, but only half of the lines for each frame. Therefore it is effectively delivering 30Hz frames, half the bandwidth of the 1080p, and most importantly, the timing requirements are easier to meet over a long cable run.
As it turns out, according to this nice explanation, the bluray DVD format is a 24 frames per second format, and it is converted to a 60fps format before going to the display. The extra 36 frames are just filler. When the signal is sent as 1080i, it has 30 full frames per second (compared with 60 for 1080p), and then the projector actually deinterlaces the signal into a 1080p display, including a full 60fps signal.
The point is that I will probably never know the difference between 1080i and 1080p on my setup, but it sure would have been nice if I could have spent an extra $50 for the right cable when my roof was open. My recommendation: test the wire before you close the roof!
Spoon - Don’t Buy the Realistic